Norma McCorvey, a pro-life “actress” who faked evangelical and Catholic conversions to be exploited or to exploit financially pro-life evangelicals and Catholics?
By Julio Severo
When Norma McCorvey, the anonymous
plaintiff in the landmark Roe vs. Wade case, came out against abortion in 1995, it stunned the world and
represented a huge symbolic victory for abortion opponents: “Jane Roe” had gone
to the other side. For the remainder of her life, McCorvey worked to overturn
the law that bore her name.
But it was all a lie, McCorvey says in a
documentary filmed in the months before her death in 2017, claiming she only did it because she was
paid by antiabortion groups including Operation Rescue.
“I was the big fish. I think it was a
mutual thing. I took their money and they’d put me out in front of the cameras
and tell me what to say. That’s what I’d say,” she says in “AKA Jane Roe,”
which premieres Friday on FX. “It was all an act. I did it well too. I am a
good actress.”
In what she describes as a “deathbed
confession,” a visibly ailing McCorvey restates her support for reproductive
rights in colorful terms: “If a young woman wants to have an abortion, that’s
no skin off my ass. That’s why they call it choice.”
Abortion was made legal in the United
States in 1973, allowing the killing of unborn babies from conception to the
last day of pregnancy. Yearly, about 1,000,000 unborn babies are killed in
abortion facilities in the U.S.
The role of McCorvey was crucial to
legalize abortion in the United States. So it was no surprise that her
conversion in 1995 was celebrated by the pro-life movement.
The Los Angeles Times report also said,
The documentary includes scenes of
McCorvey on election night 2016 — a few months before she died of heart failure
at age 69 — expressing her support for Hillary Clinton. “I wish I knew how many
abortions Donald Trump was responsible for,” McCorvey muses. “I’m sure he’s
lost count, if he can count that high.”
A DailyMail report titled “‘Jane
Roe’ of landmark US Supreme Court case made ‘deathbed confession’ that she was
PAID by evangelicals to become anti-abortion campaigner and admitted her
activism was ‘all an act’” said,
The Rev. Phillip 'Flip' Benham, one of the
two evangelical leaders who helped orchestrate McCorvey's religious conversion
in the mid-1990s, denied paying her.
But the creators of the documentary
reportedly uncovered documents showing that she had received more than $450,000
in ‘benevolent gifts’ from the anti-abortion movement.
Pro-life Christians are extremely generous
in their efforts to fight abortion, and such generosity has been interpreted by
the left-wing media as “exploitation” of her. The left-wing media refuses to
consider if she exploited generous pro-life Christians.
The DailyMail report added that in the
interview, “In addressing her activism for the religious right, McCorvey
boasts: ‘I’m a good actress.’”
Probably her performance as an actress
happened in her own “Christian” conversion. With Benham’s spiritual aid, McCorvey
was baptized and became a pro-life evangelical Christian. But a short time
later, she underwent another religious conversion: She became a Roman Catholic.
To please right-wingers, actress “McCorvey
also took part in demonstrations where he burned the LGBT flag and the Quran,”
according to the Los Angeles Times.
So she spent a short time as an
evangelical actress and many more years as a Catholic actress. I do not
understand how Christian leaders did not suspect her fast conversions.
Even though many in the pro-life movement are
silent, some are speaking up to defend McCorvey. In a report titled “Former
Jane Roe Norma McCorvey Was ‘100% Pro-Life,’ Prayed to End Abortion Just Before
She Died,” LifeNews said,
Pro-life advocates who personally knew
Norma McCorvey, the “Jane Roe” of Roe v. Wade, believe that her conversion to
the pro-life movement and Christianity was sincere.
Sincere conversion to Christianity? Even
though the pro-life evangelical and Catholic fight is important, both religions
are much different. Evangelicals focus on Jesus and the Bible as the most
important factors for the Christian life, while Catholics focus on Jesus, Mary,
saints, Bible and many extra-biblical traditions as important factors for the
Christian life.
So the “Christian” conversion of McCorvey
was contradictory and problematic.
Rob Schenck, an evangelical minister and
former leader of Operation Rescue, was also interviewed in the McCorvey documentary.
Today, Schenck is a left-wing evangelical against Trump. The Los Angeles Times
said:
Despite her visible role in the fight
against abortion, McCorvey says she was a mercenary, not a true believer. And
Schenck, who has also distanced himself from the antiabortion movement, at
least partially corroborates the allegations, saying that she was paid out of
concern “that she would go back to the other side,” he says in the film. “There
were times I wondered: Is she playing us? And what I didn’t have the guts to
say was, because I know damn well we were playing her.”
The
left-wing media, which is exploiting the deathbed confession of a pro-life
actress and portraying the pro-life movement as having exploited her, did not
want to address the issue of if a pro-life actress can exploit generous
pro-life Christians to get money. Actors and actresses can use a pro-life,
conservative, right-wing, and Christian language for years just to get money.
There is a trail of problematic issues in
the “Christian” conversion of McCorvey. In my view, the most insightful view
came from pro-life leader and attorney Rebecca
Kiessling, who said in her Facebook page:
A new documentary has Norma McCorvey,
"Jane Roe" from Roe v Wade filmed in a "deathbed
confession" in 2017 saying she was always in support of abortion rights
and was only paid to say she was pro-life. Norma had serious mental health
issues and lots of people in the pro-life movement knew it. I met her in person
when we both spoke at an event held on my birthday and I was 9 months pregnant
and had my birthmother with me. She kept wanting to cancel the event, but did
end up speaking. She was very rough around the edges, joked about her extended
years of serious substance abuse. I thought it was off that she had no interest
in meeting her daughter who she gave birth to and placed for adoption as her
case was working its way up to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Norma McCorvey and I were Facebook friends
for the time she was on Facebook, but the things she posted were extremely
bizarre. One time it was a really strange post involving a gun. Everyone was
worried about her. She'd flip on things she said or posted regularly and
started banning people as they'd inquire or call her out.
She was canceled by #ProLife speakers bureaus as a speaker because of her
erratic behavior, including no-showing for events, canceling last-minute,
saying she can't speak. She'd blame her behavior on the toll of being
responsible for over a million dead babies each year. She signed a sworn
affidavit seeking to overturn her case.
In this new documentary where she has her
"deathbed confession" that she's always been for abortion rights, who
knows what those people were doing to exploit her? Given her mental state, it's
not a shock to me that this video has come out.
People with serious mental health issues
need a real conversion to Christ. A real conversion to Christ solves such
issues, because when Jesus enters your life, nothing is left untouched and
unhealed.
McCorvey’s case shows that if as a
Christian you fight abortion, which is a worthy fight, but neglect the supreme responsibility
Jesus gave you (“go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing
them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching
them to obey everything I have commanded you,” Matthew 28:19-20 NIV), you
are just doing a social, political or ideological work, which saves no eternal
souls, and losing the opportunity to preach the whole Gospel to save souls.
The
$450,000 in benevolent gifts given to McCorvey would have been much better employed
if used to support missionaries who are preaching the Gospel, healing the sick,
expelling demons, just as Jesus did, and making disciples and teaching them to obey
everything Jesus commanded.
Portuguese version of this article: Norma
McCorvey, uma “atriz” pró-vida que falsificou conversões evangélicas e
católicas para ser explorada ou para explorar financeiramente evangélicos e
católicos pró-vida?
Recommended
Reading:
Very good assessment. I have a link to an old Priests for Life article, http://www.priestsforlife.org/testimonies/1135-norma-mccorvey-now-100-pro-life, that was written at the time of her death. The title was "Norma McCorvey now 100% pro-life." At the time I noted how odd that was, that somehow death would confer true that status on her, and that the author seemed to believe she wasn't fully pro-life while living. That article is now gone, replaced by a page that contains links to other articles about her (past and current). I wish I had saved the entire article, not just the bookmark. 'Tis a mystery...
ReplyDeleteDo not worry, Michele. The link you mentioned is saved here since 2013:
ReplyDeletehttp://archive.is/kxyvQ
Thanks, but that link only leads back to the page compiling the links. I think they removed the article that went with the headline, "Norma McCorvey, Now 100% Pro-Life!" because what's there now does not explain what the headline means. If the story you captured was from 2013, then that was 4 years before her death. She's very hard to pin down.
ReplyDeleteHere's an article in which she was quoted in 1998 as being "100% pro-life." https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/norma-mccorvey-who-was-center-roe-v-wade-abortion-rights-n722826